Green Claims by Cos Need to be Backed by Verifiable Evidence

India Releases Strict New Guidelines to Regulate Environmental Claims and Fight Greenwashing

Source and Citation: Original reporting by ET Bureau, published January 12, 2024

Analysis of this news for a layman

The article discusses India’s draft guidelines aimed at addressing “greenwashing” by companies. Greenwashing refers to exaggerated or false claims made by companies about their products or services being environmentally friendly. Common examples include labels like “eco-conscious,” “cruelty-free,” or “good for the planet.”

Under the new rules, any sustainability claims must be supported by verified evidence. This evidence could include third-party certifications, measured environmental impact data, or specific actions taken for social good.

Failure to provide documentation can lead to penalties for greenwashing under consumer protection laws in India. This could result in fines and enforcement actions. These guidelines are applicable to a wide range of entities, including companies, advertisers, endorsers, and more.

Globally, consumers and investors are increasingly demanding greater corporate accountability regarding environmental impacts. The objective is to discern legitimate claims from misleading ones and highlight companies that are genuinely taking meaningful steps to improve sustainability. The non-profit ASCI is also working on complementary industry-written standards.

Green Claims by Cos Need to be Backed by Verifiable Evidence

Impact on Retail Investors

For retail investors, these advertising guidelines provide valuable guidance for assessing the credibility of Indian companies’ commitments to ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) principles. Companies that make bold claims but struggle to substantiate them may face regulatory scrutiny or damage to their reputation.

Conversely, companies that are transparent about their targets, metrics, and sustainability programs may be seen as more attractive for investment as authentic sustainability leaders. Retail investors can incorporate these disclosures into their due diligence process. Third-party certifications and audits can also enhance confidence in a company’s sustainability efforts.

In the short term, these rules may create challenges for sectors with a history of greenwashing reports, such as consumer goods and textiles. Entire industries may need to reevaluate their marketing claims and product lines to comply with the guidelines. Investors should monitor whether enforcement actions extend beyond isolated offenders.

However, in the long term, the emphasis on independently verified sustainability data allows markets to reward authentic business model innovations that benefit the environment and society.

Impact on Industries

Industries that make environmental claims to consumers will immediately feel the impact and need to reassess their marketing strategies. Sectors like fast-moving consumer goods, textiles, cosmetics, cleaning products, and more often emphasize sustainability attributes as consumer preferences shift.

Companies that rely on vague or unsupported assertions will need to take corrective action promptly to avoid penalties. Strategies such as highlighting supplier actions may face increased scrutiny without clear targets tied to them, potentially raising compliance costs in the short term.

Nevertheless, these guidelines are likely to stimulate demand for third-party standards, data analytics, and auditors to validate sustainability programs. Verification bodies and sustainability-linked financial products can accelerate development in this area. Some leading Indian conglomerates like Tata Group have already emphasized rigorous ESG tracking, which could serve as a model for compliance.

Long Term Benefits & Negatives

These regulations enhance India’s environmental accountability and contribute to global climate action. They help prevent market saturation with meaningless slogans that hinder genuine progress.

Over time, the push for independent verification and transparent data should encourage substantial investments in sustainability by Indian companies. This can lead to innovative business models, scientifically sound ambitions, and credible programs that generate employment, exports, and global goodwill.

However, on the flip side, overly zealous enforcement in the future could discourage companies from making sincere efforts by penalizing well-intentioned aspirations that may not pan out. There is also a risk that niche imported products with eco-friendly production practices could be barred from India if they cannot obtain local accreditations. Policy stability will be crucial in navigating these potential challenges.

Short Term Benefits & Negatives

In the short term, these guidelines create a sense of urgency for Indian companies to review their marketing claims to avoid legal issues and penalties. Early adopters may gain a strategic advantage by updating their packaging, establishing certification partnerships, and adjusting their advertising strategies ahead of deadlines. However, the additional regulatory requirements may divert focus from improving industrial efficiency.

For investors, these mandates necessitate due diligence across portfolios to distinguish between genuine and dubious sustainability claims. This presents an opportunity for early movers to identify leaders and laggards in the sustainability space. However, the initial burden of gathering information without established frameworks may initially overwhelm investors.

Expect material restatements or disclosures from companies as boards and management are confronted with past exaggerated claims. Active remediation, goal-setting, and transparency can help rebuild trust and demonstrate a commitment to improvement. The intent and trajectory of sustainability efforts will become even more critical metrics for investors than the starting point.

Impact of India’s Green Claims Verification Guidelines:

Indian Companies Likely to Gain:

  • Dabur, Himalaya, Emami: These Ayurvedic and herbal products companies heavily rely on “natural” and “eco-friendly” claims. Verifiable evidence could solidify their green credentials, attracting environmentally conscious consumers and boosting market share.
  • Tata Motors, Mahindra & Mahindra: Increasing focus on electric vehicles (EVs) and green mobility positions these automakers as frontrunners in sustainable transportation. Transparent evidence of emission reduction through EVs could enhance their brand image and market valuation.
  • Greenko Group, ReNew Power, Adani Green Energy: Leading renewable energy players benefit from showcasing verifiable claims about clean energy generation and carbon footprint reduction. This transparency opens doors to ESG investors and strengthens their reputation.
  • ITC, Godrej Industries: Companies actively investing in sustainable packaging, waste reduction, and renewable energy sources can leverage verifiable evidence to gain a competitive edge and attract eco-conscious customers.
  • Environmental Consulting & Certification Firms: The need for verifiable data and certification will increase demand for services from firms like Bureau Veritas, TÜV India, and Quess Corp.

Indian Companies Potentially at Risk:

  • Companies with Vague Green Claims: Companies relying on unsubstantiated “green” or “eco-friendly” claims without concrete evidence could face legal action and reputational damage. This could impact consumer trust and lead to market share losses.
  • Fast Fashion or Consumer Goods Companies with Sustainability Claims: Brands claiming environmentally friendly practices in fast fashion or resource-intensive industries face a higher risk of scrutiny and potential greenwashing accusations. This could harm brand reputation and sales.
  • Coal-based Power Companies: As green scrutiny strengthens, companies solely reliant on fossil fuels might face pressure to diversify towards cleaner energy sources or risk losing investor confidence and future market opportunities.
  • Chemical and Petrochemical Companies: Industries with inherent environmental challenges may face difficulty in substantiating green claims. Lack of verifiable evidence could expose them to legal risks and erode consumer trust.

Global Companies:

The impact on global companies will depend on their existing sustainability practices and reliance on the Indian market. Companies with strong verifiable green credentials could benefit from increased demand for sustainable products and services in India. Conversely, those primarily relying on unsubstantiated green claims in India might face similar risks as Indian companies.

Disclaimer: This analysis is based on the information provided in the news article and should not be considered financial advice.

error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top

Subscribe to Profitnama to access all articles, explanations, stock analysis
Already a member? Sign In Here