ProfitNama

ProfitNama

Crucial WTO Meeting: India and 20 Countries Tackle Agricultural Subsidies

What's Next for the WTO?

Introduction:

India, along with 20 other countries, is set to participate in a crucial mini-ministerial meeting at the World Trade Organization (WTO) to address trade distorting subsidies in agriculture. This meeting comes in the wake of India’s criticism of the Cairns Group’s proposal to reduce agriculture domestic support entitlements, which had faced opposition from around 80 WTO members. The focus of the meeting is to provide political guidance to overcome the hurdles in agriculture negotiations, particularly regarding public stockholding. This analysis aims to delve into the implications of these developments.

Analysis of this news for a layman:

The WTO (World Trade Organization) is like a big meeting place where countries discuss rules for international trade. In this meeting, India and many other countries are going to talk about something called “agricultural subsidies.” These subsidies are like financial help that governments give to their farmers to make their products cheaper or more competitive. India didn’t like a proposal from a group of countries called the Cairns Group, which wanted to reduce these subsidies. Now, India and others want to find a solution that’s fair for everyone. They want to make sure they can keep stockpiling food to feed their people without breaking any rules. They also want to update the rules to account for inflation and use more recent prices.

Original Analysis:

The mini-ministerial meeting at the WTO is a significant event in the world of international trade. India, being one of the largest agricultural economies globally, has a substantial stake in these negotiations. Agricultural subsidies are a contentious issue because they can distort global trade by giving some countries an unfair advantage. The Cairns Group’s proposal, which aimed to reduce these subsidies, faced strong opposition from many countries, including India.

Impact on Retail Investors:

While the immediate impact on retail investors may not be pronounced, they should keep an eye on this development as it can indirectly affect sectors related to agriculture, such as agribusiness, food processing, and retail. Any disruption in global trade agreements can trickle down to affect these industries, potentially influencing the stock prices of companies within them.

Impact on Industries:

Agribusiness:

Companies involved in agriculture and agribusiness could be impacted if trade subsidies are altered. Reduced subsidies might affect the profitability of farming and related businesses. For instance, a reduction in subsidies might lead to increased production costs for farmers, which could, in turn, affect the financial performance of agribusiness companies.

Food Processing:

The food processing industry relies on a stable and consistent supply of raw materials, including agricultural products. Any changes in agriculture subsidies could lead to fluctuations in input costs, impacting this sector. For example, if subsidies decrease, food processors may face higher raw material costs, potentially affecting their profit margins.

Long Term Benefits & Negatives:

The long-term benefits could include more equitable trade policies for developing countries, ensuring food security, and modernizing outdated subsidy rules. However, the negatives might involve disruptions in supply chains, potential trade conflicts, and challenges in adapting to new regulations. For example, if negotiations result in fairer trade policies, it could open up new opportunities for developing countries to export their agricultural products, benefiting their economies in the long run. On the other hand, trade disruptions could lead to uncertainties in supply and demand, affecting businesses’ long-term planning.

Short Term Benefits & Negatives:

In the short term, the continuation of negotiations can bring stability to the markets, especially for agricultural commodities. On the downside, uncertainty in trade policies can lead to market volatility. For instance, if negotiations progress smoothly, it can provide clarity and stability to agricultural markets, benefiting both producers and consumers in the short term. However, if negotiations face challenges or uncertainties persist, it could lead to market fluctuations, impacting short-term trading strategies.

Companies that will Gain:

ITC Ltd:

As a diversified company with interests in agriculture and agribusiness, ITC could benefit from favorable trade policies that support these sectors. For example, if trade negotiations lead to more favorable conditions for agriculture, ITC’s agricultural divisions may see improved business prospects.

Nestlé India:

A major player in the food processing industry, Nestlé India could see advantages if the stability in agriculture trade leads to predictable input costs. For instance, if trade policies ensure a steady supply of raw materials, Nestlé India’s production processes may become more efficient, positively impacting its bottom line.

Companies that will Lose:

Adani Agri Logistics Ltd:

Any disruption in agriculture trade could negatively impact logistics companies like Adani Agri Logistics, which rely on smooth agricultural supply chains. For example, if trade conflicts or changes in subsidies lead to disruptions in agricultural exports, logistics companies may face challenges in transporting goods efficiently.

Britannia Industries Ltd:

Companies heavily reliant on agricultural raw materials, like Britannia, may face challenges if input costs become unpredictable. For instance, fluctuations in agricultural subsidies or trade policies can lead to uncertainty in the pricing and availability of raw materials, affecting Britannia’s production costs and, potentially, its profitability.

Potentially Impacted Companies:

Agricultural/food companies in India and other developing countries:

The article discusses India’s public stockholding program and subsidies for food producers. Indian companies like ITC Agri Business or KRBL could benefit if more subsidies are allowed. Other developing country agri companies could also be positively impacted.

Agricultural machinery and input companies:

If developing countries are allowed more subsidies, they may purchase more tractors, irrigation equipment, seeds, fertilizers, etc. Companies like Mahindra & Mahindra, Jain Irrigation, UPL Limited in India could benefit. Deere, CNH Industrial globally could also see upside.

Commodities companies:

Changing rules around agri subsidies may impact global crop prices and trade flows. Companies like Cargill, Louis Dreyfus, Bunge, ADM could be affected.

Potential Impact/Sentiment:

If more subsidies allowed:

Viewed positively for above companies as helps increase demand for their products/services. Developing country governments have more support for the agri sector and rural economies.

If stricter rules adopted:

Could negatively impact companies above as developing countries may scale back support leading to less demand. However, some view subsidies as distorting trade.

Overall uncertainty:

Mixed impact until clear outcome. Markets may see some volatility around these companies as negotiations progress. Much depends on the final decision at the 2023 WTO Ministerial Conference.

Additional Insights:

Developing countries are striving for a fair and balanced approach in trade negotiations. The potential amendment of the anti-circumvention clause and the use of more recent reference prices are indicators of their efforts to modernize trade rules. These proposed changes aim to ensure that trade rules are more responsive to current economic realities, which can benefit developing nations.

Conclusion:

The mini-ministerial meeting at the WTO highlights the complexity of global trade negotiations, particularly in the agriculture sector. While the immediate impact on retail investors may be limited, industries related to agriculture should monitor these developments closely. The outcome of these negotiations could have both short-term and long-term effects on various sectors and companies, making it a critical issue for the business world to watch.

Citation:

Author: Kirtika Suneja Title of work: “India, 20 Others to Talk Agri Subsidies at WTO Tomorrow” Date of publication: Nov 27, 2023 Publisher: Economic Times

error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top

Subscribe to Profitnama to access all articles, explanations, stock analysis
Already a member? Sign In Here